The Great Digital Narnia



Edition 521

Amol Rajan is quitting Today, leaving it with a diversity problem and a relevance problem.

Listening is so frustrating. When was the last time it produced some stop-you-in-your-tracks radio? It certainly has the resources, the clout, the talent.

Rajan came closer than most to jump-starting the programme. Now he’s had enough, and is off to thegreat digital Narnia of the creator economy.”
__



(Update: according to the Observer Emma Barnett is also “considering her next move”)

__


Meanwhile Cathy Newman is leaving Channel 4 News after 20 years.

It’s an excellent hire for Sky News – she’ll front a daily 7pm politics show as well as longer form docs and a new pod.

Good morning, it’s Monday 19th January.

Armed police in Johannesburg broke up a demo against rebel England cricketers defying the ban on playing in South Africa on this day in…?

(answer in the footnotes)

4 Quick Thoughts On:
Presenters

1) They have egos 

However this doesn’t mean you should fawn over them, refer to them repeatedly by their first name in interviews, or preface every answer with ‘that’s a good question’. None of this washes.

2) They are busy 

Presenting is a tough gig and involves some pretty furious multi-tasking. A presenter’s last priority is to put you at your ease. Expect to be ignored in the lead-up to going on air.

3) They can be mischievous 

Keep your guard up right until the last breath of an interview. A final and seemingly casual throw away personal question or off topic curve-ball can be laced with danger for interviewees.

4) They’re not bad people 

(Actually some of them are.) But the vast majority are thoroughly decent people who are very well paid to do a very difficult job. Also a chunk of them have 3:30 am daily alarm calls. At the very least, they deserve our sympathy for that…

Last week’s dilemma:

“I agreed to appear live on Programme X. I prepped, cleared my diary, only to be dropped 15 minutes before going on air. A few weeks later it happened again. Same programme. Same outcome. Now a third request.

How do I respond?”

Your verdict:

Enjoyed reading your rationale. Here are three contrasting responses: 

“My answer is always say yes if the broadcast would be of value to the charity. I explain to our spokespeople that it is the nature of news, and being readily available and helpful means journalists are more likely to come back to us in the future.”

“I think I’d push back or decline. We do appreciate how hard journalists work, how fast things can change, and how difficult a journalist’s job is. But it needs to be mutual. Treating people like that isn’t just impolite, but also a waste of their time.”


”I don’t feel it works to be too tough on live news set-up desks who do have to move with the agenda, despite their best intentions at the start of the shift. Maybe I would add a caveat though and warn the producer this request is now wearing thin, so that they get the message and don’t take you for granted or use you as a ‘place saver'”.

Ultimately it’s your call, but news is messy, inexact and frustrating. I’d certainly feel comfortable politely pointing out this has happened twice already, but I’d also say yes without hesitation. 

Here’s this week’s dilemma:

“A short clip from an interview I gave to Sky News has been posted by the broadcaster on social media. It’s accurate but heavily cropped and without context, It doesn’t really reflect what I meant. Comments are piling in. I’m annoyed, but wary of overreacting.”

What would you do (or have you done) in that situation? Vote now.

Results next week.

(Always show your marking, as my maths teacher used to say. Do
email us with the reason for your choice.)

Here’s the news diary for the week ahead…

Monday: High Court trial begins in claim by Prince Harry, Elton John and others against Daily Mail publishers.

Tuesday: Deadline for decision on Chinese embassy planning application


Wednesday:
Donald Trump speaks at Davos.

Thursday: Oscar nominations announced.


Friday:
Debate on assisted dying bill continues in the House of Lords.



Saturday: Jane Austen exhibition opens at National Archives.



Sunday: Round of 16 begins at the Australian Open.

Climate Change Fatigue? 

The Reuters Institute is tracking how people across eight countries including the UK access news about climate change….

Context and more here: Reuters Institute

Footnotes: 


A couple of you got in touch to say how much you disliked my recommendation of Good Night, and Good Luck. (Thank you for the feedback.)

We’re in Oxford and Glasgow this week.

On this day: Police in Johannesburg armed with batons and dogs broke up a demonstration against rebel England cricketers defying a ban on playing in segregated South Africa.on this day in…1990.


And finally, the Mutt Photo
: 
Leo’s new favourite spot…

Be part of the MMB. Thoughts on this week’s content, or interviews you’ve seen, heard, or (best of all) done, please let us know.

Back next Monday. Have a fantastic week.

All at Inside Edge

LinkedIn  Twitter

Inside Edge Training | The Centre, 201-203 London Road | East Grinstead , RH19 1HA GB